Possibility Does Not Mean Utility

Last week Seth Godin proposed improving US presidential primaries by holding them on social media. As an outsider who is always startled to rediscover each time I watch the West Wing that US elections actively take up one-quarter of the executive term, I fully agree that the system could be improved, and that the internet is a fertile area for finding possible improvements. However, his argument is damaged by a rather weak assumption: that anyone who can be on Facebook, is.

I’m by no means a bleeding edge tech obsessive. However, I had a personal web presence when that meant uploading HTML documents to Geocities; nearly ten years before Facebook started. And in the decade since Facebook started, I haven’t created an account. Not because Facebook is too complex, but because of what you can’t do: control the way other people will assume I want to use it.

So I would find a voting mechanism that used Facebook exclusionary, not because of privacy concerns (although I’m wouldn’t trust Facebook with anything I didn’t want publicly available), but because it would bring the endless daily round of people posting and then assuming I knew; it would be exchanging the infrequent effort of considering who to vote for and doing it, for a daily research task on all of my friends.

I fully support using social networking to make voting easier, but not at the cost of having to join a particular site. So my counter-proposal is to have a site devoted to doing this that can post to, and aggregate from, all social media (in the same way I could have this post syndicate to many other sites automatically. This makes it equally accessible to people who prefer one site over another, or don’t want to be on social media at all.

Of course, the issue of whether we should be including the voices of people who aren’t engaged enough to overcome a certain level of difficulty is a more complex one; one that would obfuscate the point I set out to make: people who face neither a lack of internet nor a lack of technical skill can have good reason not to be on Facebook (or any other site).

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Possibility Does Not Mean Utility

  1. People don’t understand one fundamental fact about US politics: the political parties are not government entities, nor are they limited to two; the Communist party put up Gus Hall for president for years, and he appeared on the ballot in many states, which brings up a further two points. The first is that, as private organizations, the parties can nominate whomever they choose by whichever method suits their fancy, and people can vote for them, against them, or ignore them. Hall entered no primaries, nor did Ralph Nader, Ross Perot, or any of the nominees from outside the two major parties. The second point is that the process within the parties is controlled by state committees. That means that if one state decides to go with your enlightened approach, nothing forces the rest to go along. That’s why we get primary elections in some states, and caucuses in others, and why some states assign delegates proportionately, and others are winner-take-all. This all varies by the specific party to boot. It’s a mess.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. There are more than two US parties – although in many countries the Republicans and Democrats would each be several parties, so the US might have broader representaton with more than the current number.

      And parties not being arms of government isn’t an obstacle; most countries regulate how private entities can act, so making a set process of candidate selection law would deal with that. Of course, implementing that law in a country where people believe free healthcare is sinful would be another issue.

      Liked by 1 person

Share Your Thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s