Inspiration: Pig Boy

In the second post on the inspirations behind the stories in State, I cover (unsurprisingly) ‘Pig Boy’, the second story in the collection. There may be spoilers ahead.

State Front Cover‘Pig Boy’ was written for a flash fiction competition, in response to the prompt ‘Contempt’.

The original story was set in a grimy pseudo-medieval village: the basic plot of a boy being bullied and revealing a magical gift was the same, but it ended with him accepting that bullying was his assigned lot in life and carrying on. I was inspired initially by the history of witch trials: rather than the logical belief that those in league with evil would be successful, accusations were most often levelled at the disadvantaged. As I had already played with successfully outwitting villagers in ‘Washed Clean’, I was interested in writing a character who was free of guile.

The then-unnamed protagonist came out sympathetically, but the cuts needed to meet the word limit left the story a very reliant on a basic grounding in Medieval witch fears. So – despite coming second in the competition – I decided to rewrite it.

The first rewrite filled in the detail, allowing it to function better without any prior knowledge; however, it still didn’t feel right, and ended up sitting in an archive file on my computer.

I read it again earlier this year when I started considering possible stories for my second collection. With the benefit of distance, I realised it wasn’t about hiding magic; it was about common cruelty. While the revelation Billy had healing powers might be a surprise to the reader, Billy didn’t change. It needed a more satisfying ending.

The obvious ending was a victory over the bullies. All Billy’s actions were out of a love of life, and his magic was removing hurts, so it didn’t seem plausible he would manage to fight back. And he wasn’t a cunning person, so a prank wouldn’t be in character either. And even if he did manage to fight or prank them, medieval society was very structured: an orphan peasant boy with a mental disability would almost certainly be punished rather than treated better.

The same issue of a rigid society made both pleading his case with adults and leaving the village seem unfeasible: even if he thought of it, trying to change his place would result in, at best, being punished.

While I was mulling in the back of my head, I continued to assemble the rest of the collection; which all had a science-fiction flavour. Rather than put Pig Boy back in the archive because I didn’t have an ending and wasn’t science-fiction, I experimented with making it science-fiction. Instead of a village fenced in by social inertia, it became a post-event settlement fenced in by an actual fence and dangerous wastes.

Without the need to overcome my expectations of medieval society, the ending came quite easily; instead of the very humble acceptance of his place in life, he could find the strength to leave.

With Billy’s magic turned into a psychic effect, there wasn’t the same ingrained moral dimension as medieval ‘magic is of Satan’, so I left the ending open enough it wasn’t clear whether the voices in the wastes had Billy’s interests at heart; ironically, putting in the morals of magic theme that drove the extensive rewrites.

What did you think about ‘Pig Boy’? Would you have preferred Billy to wreak his revenge?


Share Your Thoughts

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.